The flow of birth of fireworks to think about
big picture
https://gyazo.com/60f545eab8a3195746b378a86366eeb2
Individual Explanation
1 First, Jiro Kawakita, a cultural anthropologist, had so much data collected during his fieldwork that he was wondering how to organize it.
https://gyazo.com/7f7a075623bcb7b686e59be29639b164
2 The KJ method was created to solve that problem.
https://gyazo.com/c4d704d4ad32486e568b5ce14333514e
An important element is "bundling with a faceplate."
This reduced the apparent number of sheets, which solved the problem of "too much data and not knowing how to put it all together.
3 In brainstorming, when trying to keep a thorough record, the conversation is interrupted, and even if a one-dimensional record is kept, the whole picture cannot be grasped and only the most recent comments are affected.
4 So we took only the spatial arrangement part of the KJ method and applied it (pulse discussion). https://gyazo.com/45913846f6fd8dff2a0ccb90fa38556f
5 In the process of teaching the KJ method, Jiro Kawakita realized that many people do not do the interview part well in the first place, and this is where improvement is needed.
https://gyazo.com/c92f9c9aff0f0171fb94f6a4e5ed126c
6 "Expedition Net" was created by applying the "spatial arrangement without bundling" that was born in the pulse discussion.
https://gyazo.com/18f49e702fda0d59991f330d20dee90e
So we thought that by space-allocating the interview notes frequently, it would be better than accumulating them over a long period of time and then doing the KJ method at the end.
7 More value than expected was discovered in the exploratory net. Jiro Kawakita came to believe that the value was more important in the effect it had on later coverage than in the effect of summarizing earlier coverage
https://gyazo.com/008f2343318d17680d5a4a1cdbc2d6f0
8 If there is value in doing this before the interview, you should also do it at the beginning of the interview where there is no interview data yet. So, we can have a variant of the exploratory net that says, "I do Interior Exploration in my mind with the theme in the middle, and then sequentially put down what I find. https://gyazo.com/dca3dda68d8cb87958f0a415b57994d8
9 Birth of the word "fireworks
Seeing this characteristic of "spreading out in all directions from the central theme," Jiro Kawakita begins to say, "This is 'fireworks.
https://gyazo.com/bcf8647f2ea60c041e41abaa9a699ba8
10 Exploration nets become known as fireworks
https://gyazo.com/77425150a1f8357e4396a9dc10bb08e7
Nishio's opinion: in retrospect, here's the seed of confusion
It would be clearer in structure to call the "theme-centered variants of expedition nets" "fireworks," but the historical fact is that expedition nets as a whole have come to be called "fireworks.
The "theme-centered variants of Exploratory Fireworks" were later called "Exploratory Fireworks," and the original exploratory nets that were intended to "bring things together" were called "Integrated Fireworks. In 1986, in "KJ-Hou Omodan o Shiteiru Kangaeru", he wrote that "exploratory fireworks are the prototype of Exploratory Net" (p.300), but when Exploratory Net was introduced in "Exploratory Studies of Knowledge" in 1977, he did not introduce the method of writing themes in the middle of the page. He did not.
I think it was done as needed without clear language and was not separated as a method in the early days.
I'm a little fuzzy on the back and forth in this area because I don't have enough data.
The difference between the two methods is whether or not you think the data has been gathered sufficiently for the theme. Integrated fireworks are used when data is available, while exploratory fireworks are used when materials have not been gathered (p.300-302).
In the diagram, the exploratory fireworks are drawn as if they were only at the beginning, but in a situation where "I've done some interviews and collected some data, but I feel it's not enough for the theme," I would probably do exploratory fireworks again even in the middle of the interview.
11 Birth of Thinking Fireworks
https://gyazo.com/269a7177b9db7ca47e7128d893ceb889
Exploratory fireworks can be executed without interview data, which means they should be usable even when separated from the purpose of "doing interviews" in the first place.
---
This page is auto-translated from /nishio/考える花火誕生の流れ using DeepL. If you looks something interesting but the auto-translated English is not good enough to understand it, feel free to let me know at @nishio_en. I'm very happy to spread my thought to non-Japanese readers.